Two-alternative incremental cost and effect

Calculates the differences in cost and effect when a new intervention is compared with a relevant alternative.

Signature

Delta C = C_new - C_comparator; Delta E = E_new - E_comparator
Inputs
InputsDefinitionUnit
C_newTotal relevant cost of the new interventioncurrency per defined population or person
C_comparatorTotal relevant cost of the comparatorthe same currency and population basis as C_new
DeltaDelta E — Difference in outcome between the new intervention and comparator. Unit: the selected outcome measure
  • E_new Expected outcome for the new intervention (the selected outcome measure)
  • E_comparator Expected outcome for the comparator (the same outcome measure as E_new)

Function

Incremental comparison function

Maps the costs and effects of two healthcare alternatives to their incremental cost and incremental effect.

Try this function

Implementations

  • Excel

    Calculate incremental results

    Excel subtracts comparator values from new-intervention values using named ranges.

    =NewCost-ComparatorCost; =NewEffect-ComparatorEffect

Assumptions

  • Relevant comparator

    The comparator represents the healthcare choice actually available to the decision-maker.

  • Consistent analytical basis

    Costs and effects for both alternatives use the same perspective, population, time horizon, price basis and discounting approach.

  • Comparable outcome measure

    Effects for both alternatives are expressed using the same outcome definition and unit.

Worked examples

  • Current care compared with a new intervention

    Current care costs £10,000 and produces 4.50 QALYs. The new intervention costs £14,000 and produces 4.80 QALYs. Incremental cost is £4,000 and incremental effect is 0.30 QALYs.

    Delta C = 14000 - 10000 = 4000; Delta E = 4.80 - 4.50 = 0.30

Common errors

  • Using average instead of incremental results

    Comparing separate average costs or outcomes does not show the change produced by choosing one alternative instead of another.

Sources

  • NICE health technology evaluations manual

    NICE. Health technology evaluations: the manual. Section 4.6 Economic evaluation.

    View source

Canonical Identity

Stable URI · Machine-readable · Resolvable · CC BY 4.0