Pathway framework 3 of 8

Judging Value for Money

How to get a value-for-money result by comparing extra costs with extra health

Do you want to learn how to tell if a treatment is worth the money? You compare its extra cost with its extra health and check the result against a threshold.

7 steps

This framework organises the concepts covered at each step of the pathway on the Knowledge Map.

Before you start

Concepts from other branches of the Knowledge Tree that this pathway builds on.

  1. Step 1

    Evaluation types and frameworks

    What an economic evaluation compares, for whom, and over what period.

    12 concepts

    Why start here

    Every later method assumes a clearly framed question, so the pathway starts with what is compared and whose costs count.

  2. Step 2

    Discounting

    Why costs and health effects that arrive later count for less today, and by how much.

    10 concepts

    Why this comes next

    Most evaluations run over several years, so future costs and health need converting to present values before options are compared.

  3. Step 3

    Cost-effectiveness analysis

    Weighing the extra cost of an option against the extra health the option brings, and deciding whether that is worth paying for.

    30 concepts

    Why this comes next

    With costs and outcomes in present values, the next question is whether the extra health an option brings is worth its extra cost.

    Also on the Counting the Cost pathway

  4. Step 4

    Cost-utility analysis

    Cost-effectiveness with health measured in QALYs, the form most health technology assessment bodies ask for.

    5 concepts

    Why this comes next

    Cost-utility analysis is cost-effectiveness analysis with QALYs as the outcome, so cost-utility analysis builds directly on the step before.

    Also on the Measuring Health Gain pathway

  5. Step 5

    Cost-benefit analysis and investment appraisal

    Valuing health gains in money, so an option can be judged on whether its benefits exceed its costs.

    11 concepts

    Why this comes next

    Some decisions reach beyond health care, and valuing every outcome in money puts them on one scale.

  6. Step 6

    Budget impact analysis

    Whether a payer can afford an option in the years after the option is adopted, which is a separate question from value for money.

    10 concepts

    Why this comes next

    A cost-effective option can still be too costly to fund in a given year, so affordability is checked as a separate question.

Where to go next

Branches that take these methods further.