Binomial probability of no events among n patients

The binomial probability function with r = 0. The chance of a zero count depends on the expected count n p: it stays high when n p is small, so a rare event in a small study often gives no events at all, and a zero count does not show that the probability is zero.

Signature

P_0 = (1 - p)^n
Inputs
InputsDefinitionUnit
pProbability that any one patient has the event within the periodprobability
nNumber of patients at risk, each followed for the whole periodpatients
Output
P_0Probability that none of the n patients has the event within the periodprobability

Function

Binomial distribution of an event count among patients at risk

Gives the probability that exactly r of n patients have an event within a fixed period when each patient has the same probability p of the event and outcomes are independent. Read as a function of p for an observed count, the same expression is the binomial likelihood, proportional to p^r (1 minus p)^(n minus r), which peaks at the observed proportion r/n. The formulae below give the probability function, the chance of a zero count, the mean and variance of the count, the estimated probability with its standard error, the Wald and Wilson intervals and the logit model for binomial data in NICE DSU evidence synthesis. The conjugate beta update of a binomial probability is set out on the Beta Distribution page (HE-FM-BETA-002), and the general Wald interval for any estimate on the Asymptotic Normality page (HE-FM-AN-001).

Try this function

Implementations

  • Excel

    Zero-count binomial probability in one cell

    With named cells Prob and Patients, the formula returns the probability that no patient has the event.

    =(1-Prob)^Patients

Assumptions

  • Binomial conditions for the zero-count probability

    The conditions of HE-FM-BINOM-001 apply: a fixed number of patients followed for the whole period, a common probability and independent outcomes.

Worked examples

  • No events among 40 patients at a probability of 0.02

    With an expected count of 0.8, a 40-patient study sees no events about 45% of the time although the probability is 0.02, the setting of the article's coverage comparison.

    p = 0.02; n = 40; P_0 = 0.4457
  • No events among 40 patients at a probability of 0.15

    With an expected count of 6, a zero count has a probability of only about 0.0015.

    p = 0.15; n = 40; P_0 = 0.0015

Common errors

  • Reading a zero binomial event count as a zero probability

    No events among 40 patients is consistent with a sizeable probability: at a true probability of 0.02 the chance of a zero count is about 0.45, and the Wilson interval for 0 of 40 reaches about 0.088. Entering zero as the model probability removes the event from the model.

Sources

  • Probability of no events from the binomial function in Bayesian Data Analysis

    Gelman A, Carlin JB, Stern HS, Dunson DB, Vehtari A, Rubin DB. Bayesian Data Analysis. 3rd edition. Boca Raton: Chapman & Hall/CRC; 2013. Appendix A, Table A.2, which gives the binomial probability function for counts 0 to n; at a count of zero it reduces to (1 minus p)^n.

    View source →

Canonical Identity

Stable URI · Machine-readable · Resolvable · CC BY 4.0